Thank you for your sacrifice, Uncle Arthur
Dear Private Goddard-B36625,

Before this trip, that was how I knew you.
A rank. A name. A service number. And over 40 military service documents on file for you.
I knew your age, your family, your training, your postings, the belongings you carried, and the circumstances of your death. I had read through the documents that recorded your life in the military, and I understood the facts of your service.
But I did not really understand you. Not yet.
I just returned from Italy, and I have been thinking about you ever since.
We travelled through Monte Cassino, Ortona, Rimini, Rome, and many of the places connected to the Italian Campaign. We stood on the same ground where you and your comrades fought more than eighty years ago. We walked through Canadian, German, and Polish cemeteries. We listened to stories of soldiers and civilians.
Everything felt different once I was actually there.
Before the trip, battlefields were places I studied.
In Italy, they became places where people had been afraid, exhausted, injured, killed, and
separated from the people they loved.
….
The cemeteries affected me more than anything else.

When you read that thousands of people died in a battle or a campaign, the number can almost become too large to understand. You know it is tragic, but it becomes a statistic.
Then you walk into a cemetery.
Suddenly, thousands become one.
And then another.
And another.
Every headstone was a person.
A son.
A husband.
A brother.
A friend.
Someone who had plans for what they were going to do when they got home.
I found myself stopping over and over again to read the words their families had chosen to leave behind.


“When I cease to think of you will be when God has called me too.”
“Life’s brief race well run.”
“With Christ which is far better.”“He still lives with those who knew him, in the music and the hills he loved.”
“Thou art sadly missed for thy seat is empty.”
“We planned a beautiful future darling, only to end in a dream.”
I kept thinking about the people who wrote those words. Someone had lost the person they loved and was then asked to reduce everything that person meant to them into a few words carved into stone.
That thought stayed with me.
And somewhere among those rows of graves, “Private Goddard” started to feel too distant.
You started becoming Arthur.
I began thinking about your family rather than your file. I thought about your mother, Florence, whose name appeared again and again in the documents I had read. Your next of kin. The person you supported. Before this trip, she had been another important name in your service record.
In Italy, I started wondering what it must have been like for her when the letter arrived telling her that her twenty-year-old son was not coming home.
I wondered where she was when she read it.
I wondered who was with her.
I wondered how many times she reread it.
…

We also visited a German cemetery, and that changed the way I thought about the war too.
Walking between those graves made it difficult to think only in terms of opposing sides.
Different countries.
Different uniforms.
Different languages.
But so many of them were young men buried far away from their families.
Our professor told us a story that I do not think I will ever forget.
Years after the war, two former company commanders, one Canadian and one German,
returned to one of the battlefields with a group of RMC students.
They were standing together on the same ridge where they had fought decades earlier, talking through what had happened there.
The Canadian commander remembered believing that his soldiers had faced an overwhelming German force.
The German commander, laughing, looked at him and said,
“We were just seven.”
Once, they had stood on opposite sides of that ridge trying to defeat one another.
Years later, they stood on that same ground as friends laughing together.
There is a photograph of one of them holding an umbrella over the other.
I think that photograph would say more about war than almost anything else.
At one point, each man had been told that the other was his enemy.
That made me think about how strange war is.
Under different circumstances, the person you are ordered to fight could have been someone you laughed with, worked with, or called a friend.
…

Throughout our trip, we also saw signs of the relationship that grew between Canada and Italy after the war.
One sentence stood out: “War brought us together and peace made us friends.”
One of the most emotional moments of the trip came from a man named Tomaso. He had been only five years old during the war.
He spoke about what civilians experienced around Rimini. The violence. The raids. The fear. The rapes. The suffering of people who had no part in deciding that a war would come to their homes. Then he spoke about Canadians.
He said: “Someone knocks on my door and I don’t know who it is. I open it. And if it is Canadian, it is friends.”
He had tears in his eyes.
More than eighty years had passed.
He was five years old when those memories were created, and they were still powerful enough to bring tears to his eyes as he told us about them.
I will never forget that.It made me realize that war does not end when the fighting ends.
People carry it home.
Civilians carry it.
Soldiers carry it.
Families carry it.
Sometimes families carry it for generations…
And that is when this trip became even more personal for me. Because our family carried you too. You were never simply Private Goddard. You were my great-grandmother’s brother.
Gigi talked about you.
She talked about how much she missed you.
I knew that before going to Italy, but I do not think I fully understood what it meant.
She lived an entire lifetime after you died.
She grew older.
The world changed.
Our family grew.
New generations were born.
But you stayed twenty years old.
I kept thinking about that while walking through the cemeteries.
When I read: “To all the world he was one, but to us he was all the world,”I thought about your mother, Florence.
When I read: “As we loved him so we miss him,” I thought about your siblings. Ronald, Edith and Gladys.
When I read: “We think of him in silence, his name we oft recall, nothing
is left to answer but his picture on the wall,”
I thought mostly about your sister, Gladys (my GiGi).
And I finally understood something that the service file could never have shown me.

When she talked about you years later, she was not remembering a Canadian soldier, a hero, or a historical figure like the way we remember them.
She was remembering her brother.
You were someone she grew up beside.
Someone whose voice she knew.
Someone she had memories with that existed long before there was a war.
Someone she expected to have in her life much longer than she did.
By the end of the trip, I was not thinking about the soldier I had researched for an assignment.
I was thinking about my great-great-uncle. I kept returning to one detail from your file: the family photographs you carried with you.
Out of everything in those documents, that might be the detail that affected me most.
People carry photographs of the people they want to return to.
…
I wonder what you thought your life would look like after the war.
You were only twenty.
That is the same age that I am now.
That made it impossible for me not to think about everything you never got to have.
More birthdays.
More adventures.
More time with your family.
Maybe a wife.
Maybe children.
You should have had the chance to find out.
Instead, your story ended in Italy.
Before this trip, I understood the Italian Campaign through battles.
Monte Cassino. Ortona. Rimini. Units, objectives, dates, movements, and casualties. I still understand those things. (Definitely better as well).
But now when I think about the Italian Campaign, I think about people.
I think about Tomaso, still crying more than eighty years later.
I think about two former enemies standing together beneath one umbrella.
I think about families trying to put an entire lifetime of love into one sentence on a headstone. I think about your mother receiving a letter she never wanted to receive.
I think about your sister growing older without her brother.
…
I went to Italy expecting to understand the campaign better.
I came home understanding my family a little better too.
I understand now why Papa’s mother still spoke about you.
I understand why, after all those years, she still said she missed her brother.
Loss does not disappear because decades pass.
Sometimes it simply becomes part of the family story.
One of the inscriptions I saw said: “And life is sweeter that he lived, and heaven the happier that he’s there.”
I hope your mother could believe that.
I hope your sister could too.
I definitely can.
And I wish I could tell them that all these years later, you’re still being talked about.
I wish I could tell her that the stories made their way through the family.
That Papa, a nephew you never knew, remembered them.
That eventually they reached me. And that more than eighty years after you died, your great-great-niece travelled to Italy with the Royal Military College and learned about the campaign you were part of.
I wish I could tell her that I stood on those battlefields.
That I walked through those cemeteries.
That I read those headstones.
That I thought about you.
And that I came home understanding a little more of what she must have meant when she said she missed you.
One inscription said: “I loved him in life, I love him yet, he’s mine to remember when others forget.”
I never had the opportunity to love you in life.
I never knew your voice.
I never sat at a table with you.
I never heard your stories from you.
But my family remembered you long enough for your story to
reach me.
Your sister made sure of that.
And now I feel like I carry a small part of that responsibility too.
At the beginning of this, you were Private Goddard. B36625.
By the end of Italy, you were Arthur.
And now, writing this after coming home, I think of you differently.
You are my great-great-uncle.
You are part of my family.
And you are remembered.
Italy remembers.
Canada remembers.
Our family remembers.
And now I will too.
Thank you for your sacrifice, Uncle Arthur.
Sincerely,
Ashley
OCdt Ashley A. Hansen
Faculty of Military History
Operational History Battlefield Tour
20 Oct, 2026
Re-published with permission 11/11/2026







